Skip to content

Bread or stones?

When we pray, we sometimes experience that what we get isn’t what we asked for. Does God really give stones when we ask for bread?

(Click to listen to an audio recording of this article, read by the author: Bread or stones?)

Several years ago, I prayed hard for someone I loved and it didn’t turn out as I’d hoped or prayed for or expected. So, long story short, I was very angry with God, and raged at Him quite a bit with both fists clenched and tears running down my cheeks. I’d prayed so hard and so long and believed it would go well. I was so angry about the outcome that I felt God had let me down; I think I accused Him of being cruel. I may have even quoted chapter and verse at Him to show Him that He hadn’t kept to His promises. Part of me understood that this wasn’t the right way to go about it, but I just didn’t seem able to stop my emotions.

Then, a few months later I was asked to pray for someone else. So I did. I prayed off and on throughout the night; it was a long night. And yet to all intents and purposes my prayers didn’t affect the situation one little bit.

This time I felt that it was not God’s fault – it was mine. Was there something wrong with my prayers, my faith, my life? For some reason, God wasn’t answering my prayers. Maybe God didn’t actually like me very much. And yet, I thought I was living as a discipleA disciple is another word for a follower of Christ, one who is learning to be like his Master. As a disciple you follow Jesus Christ, who is the Master and by living like Him you become more like Him. (Matthew 16:24; 1 Peter 2:21-22)... More; I thought I had a living faith. Why was it that my prayers were delivering stones when I prayed, and not the bread I’d been promised?

God only gives bread

“So I say to you, ask, and it will be given to you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you.  For everyone who asks receives, and he who seeks finds, and to him who knocks it will be opened.  If a son asks for bread from any father among you, will he give him a stone? … If you then, being evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will your heavenly Father give the Holy Spirit to those who ask Him!” Luke 11:9-13.

So, I had to ponder how to reconcile my personal experience – I felt I had been given stones – with a fact I knew in my heart of hearts to be true because it was written in God’s Word, namely:

God only gives bread; He never gives stones.

So, why weren’t my prayers answered in the way I expected them to be?

For both the people I had prayed for, I hadn’t given much thought to the process that He wanted those people to go through. It is true that we learn to come closer to God when we suffer. When I look back at the most severe trialsTribulations or trials refer to any event or situation that comes your way that tempts you to sin; that gives opportunity for sinful thoughts and temptations to rise up in you. The tribulation or trial arises when your mind to serve God struggles against your lusts to sin. It also often refers to difficult situations that test your ability to... More in my life, I am now in a position to say (hand on heart) that I am glad that I had them and I wouldn’t have missed them for anything. I learnt more about myself and the goodness of God when I was sufferingThe Bible often mentions suffering. Though this can refer to outward, physical suffering, in the New Covenant it mostly applies to the suffering that occurs when you deny your own sinful lusts and desires and put them to death. It is an inner suffering that occurs because your lusts are not being satisfied, rather than a physical, outward one –... More, than I had when things had outwardly gone really well.

When I cry out to God in the middle of trials then He meets me with His Word. This Word makes a straight path for my feet and gives a light on my path. It does not take away the suffering, but if I follow it in complete trust and put to deathIs to overcome the temptations to sin that arise when our lusts and desires draw us to react in ways we know to be evil (i.e. pride, hatred, evil-speaking, envy etc.) It is the act of denying those thoughts and refusing to agree with them. The lust to sin is not only suppressed, but it actually dies. (Romans 8:13; Colossians... More my own will in these circumstances, then I will receive power from the Spirit to bear, to comfort, to rejoice, to hope, to suffer long and be kind.

In trials, we get this nourishment; we get access to this new life. This spiritual food can certainly be described as bread.

How should I pray?

What I can pray for is that the people I love will gain strength and faith through their trials. I can pray that they will react in a godly way and that they will be liberated from their natures under the pressures and sorrows of their trials.

Because aspects of our human natures can be hidden from our view – lust for honor might be revealed and can be rejected forcefully; likewise envy, unrest, bitterness, resentments, lack of faith and more. How much better to receive power and insight in our spirits, and not only a change in our earthlyRefers to everything of this earth, as opposed to heavenly things. Example: Earthly treasures/heavenly treasures. The earthly things pass away (are temporal), but the heavenly things are eternal. (Matthew 6:19-21; Colossians 3:2; 1 John 2:17)... More circumstances.

And instead of asking God to intervene and remove their trials, I myself will have to learn to help bear the burdens and suffering of others. I will have to learn to comfort and give counsel, to share the pain and build people up in faith. This is work, and it can be painful.

When Jesus prayed for the trialTribulations or trials refer to any event or situation that comes your way that tempts you to sin; that gives opportunity for sinful thoughts and temptations to rise up in you. The tribulation or trial arises when your mind to serve God struggles against your lusts to sin. It also often refers to difficult situations that test your ability to... More to be removed from Him “if possible,” He didn’t want to be crucified, but above all His own feelings was this one overriding fact – He wanted to do God’s will, and accepted the suffering He had to go through.

So, when God doesn’t answer our prayers for ourselves and others in the way we hope He will, when He doesn’t release people from their sufferings and trials or pain or heartache or make everything “go well,” I have found something out …

We are being offered bread, not stones.

And for those two people that I tried so desperately to extricate from their trials? After some heartache and struggle and battleAlmost all talk of battles and wars when concerning a Christian life refers to the inner battle that arises when a sinful thought tempts you. God’s Spirit and the flesh are at odds. When you have decided to only do God’s will and are being led by the Spirit, a conflict between the flesh and the Spirit arises: there is... More they both emerged with their faith in God deeper and their trust in Him stronger than ever before.

Key teachings

Explore how God’s Word challenges and empowers us to live 100% according to His will, so we no longer need to fall in sin, but can come to a life of victory.

Download free E-book

So Great a Salvation

The apostle who wrote the book of Hebrews called it “a word of exhortation.” The purpose of this booklet is to amplify and expand on that exhortation, bringing faith and salvation to all those who have a heavenly calling. All those who follow the exhortation of the book of Hebrews can attain to this great salvation.

Follow us